Blog
Early Relationships and Their Echoes: A Psychodynamic Perspective
September 27, 2024
Five minutes
Tim Collier
Our earliest moments cast long shadows. As a psychologist with a psychodynamic orientation, I have observed how childhood relationships weave themselves into adult life—shaping not only how we relate to others, but how we relate to and understand ourselves. These early patterns become what psychoanalyst Christopher Bollas calls our unthought known—influences we feel deeply, but rarely examine.
The Dance of Early Attachment
From our first moments, we begin an intricate dance with our caregivers. This dance creates what Donald Winnicott termed our 'holding environment'—the psychological space in which our earliest sense of self emerges. When this holding is 'good enough' (to use Winnicott's phrase), we develop what attachment theorists call a secure base from which to explore the world.
Yet, this dance isn't always smooth. Sometimes our caregivers, despite their best intentions, step on our toes. They might be consistently out of sync (leading to avoidant patterns), unpredictably present (fostering anxiety), or themselves struggling with unresolved trauma (potentially creating disorganised attachment). These early choreographies become our template for intimacy.
When Past Becomes Present
In my clinical work, I often witness how these early patterns resurface in adult relationships. A patient might repeatedly choose emotionally unavailable partners, unconsciously recreating the distance they knew in childhood. Another might struggle with overwhelming anxiety when their partner doesn't immediately respond to messages, echoing earlier experiences of unpredictable care.
These aren't bad habits—they're sophisticated survival strategies that once served an essential purpose.
The Therapeutic Journey
Psychodynamic therapy offers a unique space to explore these patterns. Unlike approaches that focus solely on symptom reduction, psychodynamic work invites us to understand the deeper meanings of our relational patterns. This understanding emerges not just through insight, but through the lived experience of the therapeutic relationship itself.
In the consulting room, past and present often merge. Through the phenomenon of transference, patients begin to experience and understand their relational patterns in real-time. A missed session might stir long-sanding feelings of abandonment; a moment of empathic attunement might allow for a new experience of being understood.
Beyond Repetition
While early relationships shape us, they need not define us. Through the containing space of therapy, we can begin to identify and work through these patterns. This isn't about erasing the past—it's about understanding it deeply enough that we can choose different ways of being in the present.
The goal isn't to achieve some mythical 'perfect attachment'. Rather, it's to develop what Peter Fonagy calls 'mentalization'—the capacity to understand our own and others' mental states. This allows us to respond to present relationships with flexibility, rather than rigid repetition.
A Continuing Story
Our early relationships write the first chapters of our story, but they need not write its ending. Through the therapeutic process, we can begin to author new chapters—ones that appreciate our past, while opening new possibilities for connection and growth.
The journey isn't easy, but it offers something precious: the chance to understand ourselves more deeply and to relate to others more freely. In doing so, we might find that our early relationships, while influential, are not immutable—they're rather the beginning of a story we continue to write.
Tim Collier is a psychologist at Victorian Psychology Group—a psychology practice in Camberwell, Victoria. With training in clinical psychology, Tim works with older adolescents and adults, supporting them with a range of mental health concerns.